Gyms, streaming, cars and software now sell access rather than ownership. The subscription economy lowers the price of entry and adds flexibility. It also changes what we keep and what we owe. So are we getting better at accessing things, and worse at owning them?
How the Subscription Economy Ate the One-Off Purchase
Coffee, fashion, streaming, travel, coworking and software now sell the same thing. They sell access. You no longer buy a film, a desk or a suit. You buy the right to use one for as long as you keep paying.
The scale is hard to ignore. Harvard Business Review authors cite estimates that put the subscription economy at nearly $500 billion in 2024. Those estimates project more than $1.5 trillion by 2033. The average American consumer already holds between seven and 12 paid subscriptions. The model now spans media, software, food and drink, health, e-commerce and telecoms.
Consultant Robbie Kellman Baxter, author of The Forever Transaction, described the shift on HBR’s IdeaCast in 2020. She called it a move from ownership to access. Her example was a Porsche subscription. It lets a driver swap an SUV for a sports car within the same week.
Why Access Feels Better Than Owning
Ownership brings costs beyond the price tag. Access moves most of them onto the provider. Baxter names three benefits. Customers skip repairs, always get the latest version, and pay in small instalments instead of one large bill.
Flexibility has also become a value in itself. Many people move cities, change jobs or work remotely. A desk, a car or a wardrobe can feel like a commitment they would rather not carry. Access lets them change course without selling anything. That logic helps the model spread far beyond software.
Cars show both the appeal and the limits. Deloitte surveyed more than 1,500 UK consumers in October 2023. It found that 18% favoured a car subscription. Among 18-to-34-year-olds, the figure rose to 28%. Yet 52% of all respondents showed no interest. Deloitte partner Jamie Hamilton said younger drivers value flexibility and choice.
So access is a widening option, not a universal preference. Younger drivers lean towards it. More than half of respondents still want no part of it.
Membership as Belonging
The word “membership” matters here. A subscription suggests usage, whereas a membership suggests participation. The gym is the clearest case.
EuropeActive and Deloitte counted 75.5 million fitness-club members across Europe at the end of 2025. That is 4.1 million more than a year earlier. Revenue rose 9.1% to €39.1 billion, partly because each member paid more. Basic-Fit alone served 5.8 million members.
The habit still has room to grow. Club membership covers 9.3% of Europe’s population. The United States sits near 25%.
Access can also spread beyond the person who pays. Deloitte’s 2023 UK research found that 35% of people with streaming access shared at least one subscription outside their home. Among people using someone else’s account, 57% said they would stop watching if sharing were banned. Only 15% said they would take out their own subscription. In other words, who owns the account matters less than who can get in. Many would rather go without than pay.
The Fatigue Paradox
Access has a price, and people feel it. Chargebee surveyed 1,454 consumers in the US and UK in 2025. Some 44% said subscriptions take a moderate or significant bite out of their budget. Ninety per cent noticed a price rise, yet only 58% felt it was justified.
Still, 80% had no plans to consume less overall. Chargebee sells billing software, so read its framing with care. Even so, the pattern is telling. People are tired of paying, not of accessing.
Deloitte’s UK data show the same push and pull. The average number of streaming subscriptions per person rose to 2.62 in 2023. Meanwhile, 21% of subscribers had cancelled a service in the previous year. Deloitte linked the rise in cancellations partly to cost-of-living pressure.
A 2026 HBR study adds a twist. It tracked 1.4 million people in a field experiment with a major European newspaper. Automatic renewal kept subscribers longer in the short run. But it suppressed trial sign-ups so sharply that auto-cancel ultimately produced more paying subscribers, according to the authors. The finding suggests that people weigh the exit before they enter. We want the access, but we fear the lock-in. That tension is the core of subscription fatigue.
What We Quietly Give Up
Ownership offers something a membership rarely does: a finish line. You pay once, and the thing is yours. You can lend it, repair it, resell it or leave it in a drawer. A membership asks you to keep paying, or the access stops.
The trade is also uneven. An owner decides how long an object lives. A provider can change the price, the catalogue or the terms. That is why the exit matters as much as the entrance.
European lawmakers now push on both sides of this trade. Member states had until 31 July 2026 to transpose the Right to Repair Directive. It builds a right to repair into EU law. Campaigners at Repair.eu warned days before the deadline that only a handful of states had finished.
On the access side, the Commission plans to table its Digital Fairness Act in the final quarter of 2026. The European Parliament’s legislative tracker lists difficult cancellation and renewal of digital subscriptions among the problems behind it. Both files suggest a shared idea. Consumers should be able to leave, and to keep what they buy in working order.
So are we getting better at accessing things and worse at owning them? Probably both. Access has never been easier to enter, sample and drop. Ownership is turning into a choice rather than a default. That is not necessarily a loss. What do we gain when we stop owning things, and what do we quietly give up?
Key Sources
- Key Sources
- Harvard Business Review: Should Your Subscription Business Use Auto-Renew?
- HBR IdeaCast: Every Business Can Be a Subscription Business
- Deloitte UK: Younger drivers most likely to favour a subscription service for cars over ownership
- Deloitte UK: One-in-three people with streaming subscriptions share accounts with other households
- EuropeActive: Strong growth in members and revenues for European health & fitness market in 2025
- Chargebee: Cancel Anytime? Consumer Survey Says That’s Why They Stay
- Repair.eu: The Right to Repair Directive — what changes on 31 July?
- European Parliament: Digital Fairness Act
Subscribe to EuroLuminant for independent European journalism.



