Ask a supporter why they follow their club and the answer is rarely about trophies. It is about a neighbourhood, a family and a sense of belonging. New research and recent fights over ownership show why. Across Europe, a club is a place to belong, and a place to defend.
Why a Club Feels Like Home
Why do people tie their identity to a team? One answer comes from political scientist Jonas Biel of Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz. His study, published in May 2026 in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, surveyed fans in Germany, Spain, Poland and Norway.
The survey ran in early 2023 and reached 7,040 people. After filtering, Biel analysed 3,685 fans. They scored their sense of belonging from 0 to 10. Club identity averaged 6.13. National fan identity scored 5.57. Identification with a wider European fan community averaged 5.29.
The order is telling. The club comes first, then the nation, then Europe. Yet the European score is far from zero. Biel finds it forms a distinct identity, not a simple extension of club loyalty.
The study has limits. It shows associations, not causes. It covers fans only, in four countries. Still, the pattern fits what supporters say: the local club is the anchor.
When a Club Is Also a Rulebook
Some clubs write that identity into their rules. Athletic Club in Bilbao signs players who are native to the Basque Country or trained there. One profile traces the policy to the club’s founding in 1898. The club takes pride in it, though critics blame it for limiting success.
In Germany, the 50+1 rule protects a different idea. Members of a club’s parent association must hold a majority of voting rights. That keeps control with members, not outside investors. Bayer Leverkusen, VfL Wolfsburg and Hoffenheim hold exemptions tied to long-standing backers.
The rule remains contested. On 12 August 2026, the Bundeskartellamt said 50+1 is “permissible under current antitrust laws.” Its president, Andreas Mundt, added a condition. The rule must be “applied consistently and without unjustified distinctions.”
Neither policy is simple. Athletic’s approach limits its talent pool. The German model has exceptions that fans debate. Both show that supporters value rules that keep a club rooted.
When Fans Defend the Club
In April 2021, twelve clubs announced a breakaway European Super League. Within two days, it collapsed. The plan had promised a closed core of permanent members, with backing from JPMorgan Chase. Hundreds of fans protested outside Chelsea’s stadium, and the team bus could not pass. Clubs then withdrew one after another. Liverpool captain Jordan Henderson said, “we don’t like it and we don’t want it to happen.”
Fans were not the only pressure. Manchester United cited its fans, the UK government and other stakeholders. Still, the episode showed that supporters see a club as more than a company.
Organisations now give that feeling a voice. Football Supporters Europe calls itself “the democratic, passionate voice that represents the interests of supporters.” National supporters’ groups, local groups and individuals can join. Biel’s study points the same way. Fans who back collective representation are more likely to feel part of a European fan community.
Who Gets to Belong?
A club’s identity is not fixed. Migration has reshaped it, and the story is mixed.
Berlin’s Türkiyemspor shows one path. Founded in 1978 in Kreuzberg as Izmir Spor, it took its name after welcoming members from beyond Izmir. Chairman Murat Dogan told openDemocracy in 2013, “We went from being a Turkish club to a Berlin club.” He said the neighbourhood and club represent each other.
That story is not a guarantee of welcome. A 2021 study in the International Review for the Sociology of Sport tested this. Researchers sent mock membership applications to more than 1,600 German amateur clubs. Applicants with foreign-sounding names were significantly less likely to be invited to participate. The authors say these clubs are “not as permeable as they are often perceived to be.”
This is amateur football, not the Bundesliga. Still, it matters for fan culture. A club that says it represents its neighbourhood must ask who counts as part of it. UEFA lists anti-discrimination among its social aims, and its page names the FARE Network in the fight against racism. Good aims need proof in local practice.
A Global Game, a Local Meaning
Globalisation is changing what “local” means. Biel finds that European fan identity is linked to younger age, higher education and more international football consumption. It also rises with attachment to Europe and trust in other people.
That raises a question. Is this wider identity open to everyone? Biel notes that it may be somewhat privileged. Its ties to education and away-match attendance suggest access depends on resources. Germany scored lower than Spain, which he links to strong national fan organisations. He links Norway’s lower score to its distance from the EU and its peripheral place in football.
The finding does not mean the local club is fading. Club identity still ranked highest. It suggests that fans now live with layers of loyalty. They can support a neighbourhood team and feel part of a Europe-wide crowd.
Sources I read do not show whether such loyalty passes from parents to children. That needs separate research. The cases above do suggest what fans guard most. They defend rules that keep clubs tied to members, places and people.
In the end, fans do not give their identity to a sports team by accident. They give it to a shared place and a shared story. That is why a fight over ownership or entry can feel personal.
Key Sources
- Jonas Biel: Belonging to a community of European fans? European common in-group identity formation through football fandom (Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 2026)
- Football Supporters Europe
- Bundesliga: The 50+1 rule explained
- The Star: Bundesliga’s 50+1 ownership rule permissible under antitrust laws, Bundeskartellamt (12 August 2026)
- The New Ultras: The history of Athletic Club Bilbao’s cantera policy (2016)
- Bloomberg: Europe’s rebel soccer league collapses after fans force exit (April 2021)
- openDemocracy: My Turkey, Berlin, immigration and the amateur football scene (2013)
- Nobis et al.: (Not) being granted the right to belong, amateur football clubs in Germany (2021)
- UEFA: Social responsibility
Subscribe to EuroLuminant for independent European journalism.



