11.6 C
London
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Did Luxury Become Too Expensive for Its Own Good?

Date:

Related stories

Who Shapes the Future of Design? The Rise of the Nue Black Aesthetic

The Nue Black Aesthetic at London's Design Museum asks...

Housing Moves Up the EU Agenda as Ministers Prepare for Dublin Meeting

European housing ministers are due to meet in Dublin...

In Belturbet, Water Tells the Story of a Landscape Shared Across Borders

An event programme in County Cavan brought geology, climate...

200 Years of Photography: What Is a Photograph Worth in the Smartphone Age?

Photography turns 200 in 2026 and 2027, and museums...

European luxury stocks just hit their lowest levels in years. HSBC downgraded both LVMH and Burberry this week. Analysts warned the back half of 2026 “won’t get any rosier.” But the sharpest read on this moment isn’t about one bad quarter. It’s about who luxury brands priced out along the way.

A Downgrade About Momentum, Not Collapse

On 9 September, HSBC cut LVMH and Burberry from Buy to Hold. Analysts flagged limited visibility into the second half of 2026 and a tougher run of year-on-year comparisons. It followed a rough week for the sector generally. The STOXX Europe Luxury 10 index hit its lowest level in nearly three months on 3 September. That extended its year-to-date decline to 19%. LVMH shares slipped to their lowest price since 2020.

HSBC’s reasoning is more nuanced than “sell now.” The bank isn’t arguing luxury demand has collapsed. It’s arguing that growth is decelerating from an already-modest base, making the second half harder to forecast with confidence. That distinction, between an outright downturn and a slowing rate of recovery, shapes everything else in this story.

The Numbers Actually Point to Recovery

Here’s the part that complicates a simple “luxury is dying” narrative. LVMH’s first-half 2026 results showed organic growth of 2%, accelerating to 3% in the second quarter. Fashion and Leather Goods, the division housing Louis Vuitton and Dior, returned to growth after seven consecutive quarters of decline. Watches and Jewellery grew 9% for the half.

Burberry told a similar story. Comparable store sales rose 5% in its first fiscal quarter, with the Americas up 12% and Greater China up 9%. Gen Z customer numbers grew by double digits. Neither company is shrinking. What’s actually happening is more specific. Growth has returned, but not fast enough, or broadly enough, to satisfy investors who remember the sector’s pre-2023 boom years.

Where the Aspirational Middle Class Went

The more interesting story sits underneath the earnings calls. Industry coverage of LVMH’s results noted that luxury brands increasingly depend on a small cohort of ultra-wealthy clients. So-called aspirational consumers, middle-income shoppers stretching to buy a status symbol, remain squeezed by inflation instead. Bain & Company has separately estimated the scale of this shift. Tens of millions of these consumers have either stopped buying luxury goods or been priced out entirely in recent years.

The mechanism behind that shift is straightforward. Handbag and accessory prices at several major houses climbed sharply since 2019. In some cases, they rose 50% to 70%, according to industry analysis. That pricing strategy worked brilliantly for margins while aspirational buyers kept stretching to afford it. Once prices outran what stretching could cover, those buyers simply stopped showing up. Luxury may have optimised itself out of the mass market it spent two decades building.

A K-Shaped Luxury Market

China illustrates the same divide from a different angle. Bain’s research shows the mainland luxury market contracted 3% to 5% in 2025. That’s a sharp improvement from a 17% to 19% drop in 2024. Bain senior partner Bruno Lannes described this as “the start of a recalibration phase,” not a genuine rebound. Brands offering either affordable entry points or true ultra-premium exclusivity fared best. The middle ground struggled.

That pattern extends well beyond China. Analysts increasingly describe a K-shaped luxury economy: wealthy consumers keep spending freely, while everyone just below them pulls back. Hermès and Richemont skew toward genuine wealth rather than aspiration. Both have weathered the slowdown better than brands more dependent on stretched middle-income shoppers. The story isn’t luxury collapsing. It’s luxury sorting itself into two increasingly separate markets.

From Owning Things to Buying Experiences

One more shift deserves attention. Bain’s research consistently finds that experience-based spending, travel, wellness, fine dining, is growing faster than spending on physical luxury goods. Chinese consumers, in particular, have shifted spending away from handbags and toward these categories.

That’s a meaningful cultural change, not just a demand-shift statistic. For decades, luxury sold status through visible ownership: a logo, a bag, a watch. If growth increasingly comes from experiences rather than objects, something bigger shifts too. The industry’s core product, a thing you own and display, may matter less than it used to. Burberry’s own strategy already reflects some of this tension. It leans into heritage and craftsmanship, and what the company calls value within a luxury context, rather than pure exclusivity through price alone.

Put together, these threads describe an industry recalibrating rather than declining. Luxury brands spent years raising prices, expanding margins, and courting a widening base of aspirational buyers. That model generated extraordinary growth, then eventually ran into its own limits, once prices climbed further than stretching could cover. What comes next may not be a return to the old growth curve at all. It may be a smaller, more polarised market, built primarily around people for whom the price was never really the point.


Key Sources


Subscribe to EuroLuminant for independent European journalism.

Kay
Kay
The reporter/editor based in London

Subscribe

- Never miss a story with notifications

- Gain full access to our premium content

- Browse free from up to 5 devices at once

Latest stories

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here